HOME | Pop's Custard

top of page

Tel: 262-251-3320 - N87W16459 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051 - Open Tues-Sun 11am-9pm

Big Jack

Our flavor of the the day is fast becoming a favorite with our customers but we are sure it has everything to do with the man and not the custard. In honor of Big Jack, we are having the flavor appropriately named Big Jack! It is our butter pecan custard with salted pecan pieces and chocolate chips! We sure do miss you!

Previous Flavors

- Notice -

We are extremely grateful for all of our customers and for the support shown by the community. With that in mind, we are extremely busy and selling out of custard faster than we can make it. If you are ordering custard to go, please be aware that it will most likely be FRESHLY PACKED directly out of the machine and can melt quickly during a long commute home.

Mucho Macho Burger

Loaded Fries_edited.jpg

OUR MENU

Simply Irresistible!

Pop's Frozen Custard is a family-owned frozen custard and burger staple of Menomonee Falls, WI. Our menu features a wide variety of delectable treats that are made with the freshest ingredients and are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

Decorated Dinning Table

Pop's Custard Events

Pop's Custard Catering

Indulge your guests with our custard event catering, featuring delicious frozen custard that can be customized to suit any occasion. Choose from a variety of sundaes and delectable toppings to create a delightful dessert experience that everyone will love!

Contact us below for more information!

VISIT US

A Charming Destination

Pop's Frozen Custard is located in downtown Menomonee Falls near the Menomonee River, Lime Kiln Park, Krueger's bowling center, and the Kohl's splash pad.

bottom of page